All buyers are liars.
That’s one of the first things I learned when I got into the car biz back in 1981. Whenever a potential customer would tell me they wanted to:
A) go home to think about it…
B) go to lunch to think about it…
I knew what they were thinking about was how to get a better deal someplace else.
I knew they weren’t coming back.
What they were doing was going to the dealer down the street with the knowledge they had just gotten from me…and they would buy there. Unfortunately, the car buying experience has, over the last 50 years or so, become a very adversarial process. Car salesmen have had to come up with creative ways to ‘get the sale’. And the car buying public has had to come up with ways to ‘get the best deal’. Who can blame either side?
The new car salesman has tons of competition. A customer can buy the same make and model with the same color and options at the same franchised dealer on every street corner. So the ‘new car’ consultant has to be either a Super salesman…or he has to lie to make the sale. The Super salesmen did not lie. They didn’t have to. Most of the top car sales guys I know treat their customers well. Really take care of them. These Super salesmen know that repeat business, word of mouth business, is what pays the mortgage and puts food on the table.
But the mediocre salesman…that’s another story. These guys have to try every trick in the book to get the customer to buy…and to buy NOW. Their jobs depend on making the sale. Once the customer leaves ‘to think about it’, once they leave the store without buying, the sale is lost.
And because most dealers treat their salesmen as just another piece of meat…they’re a dime a dozen…the pressure put on the sales force is tremendous. Turnover in some of the bigger ’stores’ can be a weekly thing. I knew one store in LA that turned over 70% of its sales force monthly…7 out of 10 salesmen got canned every month! So these guys will do anything to make the sale and to keep their job. And you know what…I don’t blame them…well, not much. Selling new cars is a dog eat dog business. Especially in these times. Most ‘new car’ salesman are new to the business otherwise they would work a ‘used car’ lot. That’s where the real money is made.
Think about it. New car sales are one of the most competitive selling jobs on the planet. A customer can buy from any dealer that has the make/model he wants. All dealers pay the same price from the factory, so they all have the same ‘wiggle room’. And the customer can go down the street and ’shop’ the price because there probably is another dealer of that make within 10 miles* who might just take a smaller profit to move his inventory.
But think of the ‘used car’ salesman. His cars are basically ‘one of a kind’. Since it’s used, his cars will be of different years, makes, models, mileages, colors, options, and condition then the guy down the street. VERY HARD to shop the price! The dealer also paid a ‘unique’ price for his car, so he has room to negotiate, up or down. The used car salesman just needs to sell that car, and he has literally no competition.
So guys, if you want to make ‘the big bucks’ you absolutely must sell used. It’s the only way to make it in this business.
Used Car Dealer in Melrose, Massachusetts circa 1939
*although things are changing rapidly now that the big 2 are eliminating dealerships left and right–Chrylser loses nearly 800 and GM a whopping 1500!